When did micah become a rat

I like all the points made from you and with your help i ll conclude that micah wasas he saida survivor. Lets analyze him :. He is an Outlaw and there is no honor being an Outlaw when did micah become a rat kill for some money or even for joy or a pointless revenge about getting your beloved guns backhe enjoys the outlaw life and being a member or even a leader of a ganghe is sneaky cunning and smarthe is a good speacher using deep meanings he is a good shooterhe can survive alonehe will use everything he has to survive or avoid to put himself on bad situationhe keeps contesting with Arthur a stronger member with stronger relationship with the whole journaling tiktok that explains why he ll set him up , when did micah become a rat.

Log In Sign Up. What do you need help on? Cancel X. Topic Archived Page 1 of 2 Last. Sign Up for free or Log In if you already have an account to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts. UnfairRepresent 5 years ago 1.

When did micah become a rat

Well according to Milton, They picked up Micah when they returned from Guarma, and i think that Micah ratted out the gang because he was afraid he would be killed if he didn't. This is also backed up by the fact that Micah seems to rather enjoy being in the gang, and even feels like he betrayed them after he was arrested in Strawberry. Why did he become a rat? While the rest of the gang brush it off, Micah may have kept it in mind, knowing that it might come in useful one day. By the time the five gang members had returned from Guarma, it was clear that Dutch was going mad and that the gang was on its last legs. Furthermore, it had reached the point where Dutch placed full trust in him, so there would be little chance of being discovered. He wanted to torment Arthur about Micah being the rat before killing him, so he would give him the full details of it. In essence, why would he lie? Admittedly, the Blackwater ferry robbery is perhaps a cause for suspicion regarding his true loyalties, but it could perhaps be because it would be such a big take and that it may result in a massive shootout, which Micah always enjoys. He got into trouble in the first place by killing two people in a bar fight, after seeing some people who he knew. At no point does Lenny say that he was turned or that the people he met were Pinkertons - undercover or not. Just Micah being Micah. Considering how Micah committed mass murder arguably the most major crime of all , why would they keep him around?

Killed Susan, Arthur himself, made a puppet out of Dutch etc. Even it was some plan to get rid of Arthur and Sadie, John confirmed that he was indeed supposed to be hanged eventually, so why would that be the case.

Log In Sign Up. What do you need help on? Cancel X. Sign Up for free or Log In if you already have an account to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts. Canderous87 posted

I mentioned this in an earlier reply. They are resourceful enough to find out via other means. In all chapters, it appears that the gang are being watched more closely than they think, and this is very plausible in chapter 4. The whole theme of the game is that the West is dying and forces in support of civilisation i. Assuming Micah was a rat before Guarma, then he couldn't have worked with the Pinkerton's directly, due to Milton's comment.

When did micah become a rat

Why would Milton be reluctant to say that Micah was responsible for the bank robbery? Why would he not want Arthur to know that Micah was a rat from the start? Why would it need to be a secret anymore? For me, that makes it likely that Micah betrayed the gang after returning from Guarma, as Milton stated. Yes but if micha was only a rat after guarma then how do you explain the bank robbery and the blackwater ferry robbery and how do you explain all the attention that micha brings to the gang across the game there is no other way to look at it micha was a rat from the start or at least did it all on purpose to mess up the gang. The Blackwater massacre could just be that lawmen and Pinkertons had kept an eye on them for a while, and they thought it was a good moment to strike.

Neurologist salary

So how did they know? Ask A Question. Ganon 5 years ago 26 Why is there even debate about this? The only option was left to rat out the gang as an exchange of Her family immunity. What kind of deal could Milton offer Micah anyways??? Canderous87 5 years ago 28 Ganon posted Topic Archived Page 1 of 2 Last. StockpileThomas 5 years ago 4 UnfairRepresent posted Until it turn out to be setup and only guys present here was Arthur, John, Sean and Charles. If you know about Abigail origins then you will know she was thief and pros brought by uncle in the gang and literally abused by everyone. Redemption Undead Nightmare Redemption 2. Raylen View Profile View Posts. So How do you explain all the other jobs failing? Micah clearly at some point decided he was gonna double-cross whoever was paying him, though those reasons remain unclear and many, ranging from Micah starting to naturally like Dutch and wanting to make him see his true potential as a criminal to Micah seeing potential in members like Arthur Morgan, John Marston, and even Sadie Adler as effective and prosperous criminals themselves and to join Micah in a new gang, or Micah simply wanting to usurp a lead role from somebody in the gang for his own reasons. October 19, at am.

Red Dead Redemption II featured a lot of characters who operated under a morally gray umbrella.

Per page: 15 30 Will it respawn? GSid 5 years ago 2. Micah is a character with high loyalty to survive until the epilogue managed to collect money from blackwater, dutch destroying all the achievements of the gang itself ending micah's life. He doesn't care if he works with the Pinkerton or not. Howler 5 years ago 29 Canderous87 posted He was always going to be 2nd in command when Hosea passed, it was the whole reason he was in the gang, and the whole reason he treated the rest of the gang like crap and didn't care what they thought. The Boat robbery, The Train robbery, the bank robbery. SeekAndDestroy2 5 years ago Showing 1 - 15 of 68 comments. Never confirmed. Everything good about Dutch is because he listened to Hosea, and when he switched to Micah he became more like Micah. Explore Wikis Community Central. While Molly admits to it, Milton indirectly denies this by not mentioning her betrayal at all.